After a Florida car accident, the cost of repairing or replacing your car is generally paid from one of two places: the at-fault driver’s property damage liability (PDL) coverage, or your own collision or comprehensive coverage if your policy includes it. Personal injury protection (PIP) does not pay for vehicle damage, and uninsured motorist coverage is a bodily injury coverage. Which route applies depends on fault, the coverage each driver carries and the policy terms.

In this guide

This guide offers general information for people in Plantation and Broward County. It is not legal advice, and each matter depends on its facts.

The at-fault driver’s property damage liability coverage

Florida requires every owner or operator of a motor vehicle registered in the state to be able to respond in damages for liability “because of damage to, or destruction of, property of others in any one crash” in the amount of $10,000 (section 324.022(1), Florida Statutes). The requirement may be met with a policy providing at least $10,000 of property damage liability coverage, or at least $30,000 in combined property damage and bodily injury liability coverage for any one crash.

If the other driver caused the crash, a claim for your vehicle damage may be made against that driver’s PDL coverage. Under section 626.9743(2), when liability and damages owed under the policy are reasonably clear, an insurer may not recommend that a third-party claimant make a claim under his or her own policy solely to avoid paying the claim. If the damage exceeds the at-fault driver’s PDL limit, the remainder may depend on your own coverage or on the at-fault driver personally.

Your own collision or comprehensive coverage

The coverages Florida requires of a vehicle owner are PIP, under section 627.733(1)(a), and property damage liability, under section 324.022. Coverage for damage to your own car, called collision coverage for crashes and comprehensive coverage for events such as theft, fire or weather, is a matter of your own policy. If you carry it, you may make a first-party claim with your own insurer, subject to your deductible and the policy terms, regardless of fault.

Whether you claim under your own policy or the other driver’s, under section 626.9743(3), an insurer that elects to repair the vehicle and requires a particular repair shop must have the vehicle restored to its physical condition as to performance and appearance immediately before the loss, at no additional cost other than as stated in the policy. Under section 626.9743(4), an insurer may not require replacement parts that are not at least equivalent in kind and quality to the damaged parts in fit, appearance and performance.

Why PIP does not pay for your car

Under section 627.736(1), PIP provides up to $10,000 in medical and disability benefits and $5,000 in death benefits “resulting from bodily injury, sickness, disease, or death” arising out of the ownership, maintenance or use of a motor vehicle. Vehicle damage is not among those benefits. Uninsured motorist coverage is similar in scope: under section 627.727(1), it protects insured persons legally entitled to recover from owners or operators of uninsured motor vehicles “because of bodily injury, sickness, or disease, including death.” The UM coverage the statute requires does not pay for vehicle damage. See our guide on uninsured and underinsured motorist questions.

Total loss: how value is set

Under section 319.30(3)(a), a motor vehicle is a “total loss” for title purposes when an insurance company pays the owner to replace the wrecked or damaged vehicle with one of like kind and quality. For an uninsured vehicle, the statute treats the vehicle as a total loss when the cost of repair at the time of loss is 80 percent or more of the cost of replacing it with one of like kind and quality. A vehicle is not a total loss if the insurer and owner agree to repair rather than replace it.

When your own policy settles a total loss on the basis of actual cash value or replacement with a vehicle of like kind and quality, section 626.9743(5) requires the insurer to use one of these methods:

  • A cash settlement based on the actual cost to purchase a comparable motor vehicle, including sales tax where applicable, drawn from two or more comparable vehicles available locally within the preceding 90 days, from a generally recognized used-vehicle database or guidebook, which the insurer must document or identify on request, or from two or more quotations from local licensed dealers.
  • A replacement vehicle that is a specified comparable vehicle, at no cost other than the deductible and any betterment. A comparable vehicle is one by the same manufacturer, of the same or newer model year and similar body type, with similar options and mileage, in as good or better condition, and available for inspection within a reasonable distance of your residence.
  • A settlement on another basis, supported by documentation, with deductions itemized and explained in writing on request.
  • Any other method agreed to by the claimant.

Under section 626.9743(6), deductions for betterment or depreciation must be itemized by dollar amount and explained in writing if you ask. Under section 626.9743(9), the insurer may defer paying sales tax until you actually incur it, so keep your purchase or repair paperwork.

Rental cars and crashes

If the crash involved a rented or leased vehicle, section 627.7263(1) makes the valid and collectible liability insurance or PIP insurance covering the lessor primary unless the rental or lease agreement states otherwise in at least 10-point type on its face. The statutes discussed here do not address who pays for a rental car while your own vehicle is repaired. That depends on whether your own policy includes rental reimbursement coverage and, if another driver was at fault, on how your property damage claim against that driver is resolved. See our guide on rental car crashes under Florida’s no-fault law.

Getting the other driver’s insurance information

At the scene, section 316.062(1) requires a driver involved in a crash with injury or vehicle damage to give his or her name, address and vehicle registration number. Under section 316.065(1), the driver of a vehicle involved in a crash with injury, death, or damage to a vehicle or other property in an apparent amount of at least $2,000 must immediately notify the local police, the county sheriff or the Florida Highway Patrol.

Under section 316.066(1), both the long-form and short-form crash reports must include the names of the insurance companies for the parties, and each party must give the officer proof of insurance, which must be documented in the report. Under section 316.066(2)(b), the report may be made immediately available to the parties involved, their legal representatives and their insurers. If you have a crash report but no policy number, under section 324.242(2) the department must release the policy number for a vehicle in the crash to any person involved, that person’s attorney or that person’s insurer, on request and proof of the crash report. See our guides on Florida traffic crash reports and hit-and-run crashes.

Fault and shared fault

A third-party property damage claim depends on the other driver’s fault. Under section 768.81(2), fault chargeable to the claimant proportionately reduces the damages awarded in a negligence action, and under section 768.81(6), a party found to be more than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover any damages. See our guide on what to do when the other driver disputes fault.

Payment after a settlement, and the lawsuit deadline

Once you and an insurer agree in writing to settle a claim, section 627.4265 requires the insurer to tender payment according to the agreement no later than 20 days after the settlement is reached. Payment may be conditioned on a mutually agreeable release, and a late payment bears interest at 12 percent per year as the statute provides. Read any release before signing it. See our guide on settlement releases.

If a negligence lawsuit against the at-fault driver is needed, section 95.11(5)(a) provides that an action founded on negligence must be commenced within two years. The 2023 law that set this period, chapter 2023-15, Laws of Florida, applies to causes of action accruing after its effective date, March 24, 2023. The deadline for a particular matter depends on its facts. See our guide on Florida personal injury lawsuit deadlines.

Common questions

Does the other driver’s insurer have to pay the full repair cost?

It depends on fault and on the at-fault driver’s policy limit, which may be as low as the $10,000 minimum under section 324.022(1). Amounts above the limit may depend on your own collision coverage or on the at-fault driver personally.

Can I pick my own repair shop?

Section 626.9743(3) applies when an insurer requires a particular shop: the vehicle must be restored to its pre-loss condition at no additional cost beyond what the policy states. Whether you may choose a different shop depends on the policy terms.

Can I keep my car after a total loss?

Section 319.30(3)(b) contemplates an owner retaining a vehicle in a total loss settlement; the department then issues a salvage certificate of title or certificate of destruction to the owner. The settlement terms depend on the policy and your agreement with the insurer.

Related guides

For related topics, see our guides on Florida traffic crash reports, rental car crashes under Florida’s no-fault law and our accident consultation checklist.

Discuss your next step

The Right Law Firm, P.A. assists with Florida car and motor vehicle accident claims from its Plantation office. To request a free initial consultation, call 954-633-7744 or contact our team.

General information only. Each matter depends on its facts. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship; representation requires an agreement. Your case may be referred to another lawyer. Do not send confidential documents through the public inquiry form.

Sources and further reading