Two separate claims after a work-related crash

If you were driving for your job in Florida and another driver caused the crash, two sets of rules apply at once: chapter 440, the Workers’ Compensation Law, for what your employer owes, and the ordinary negligence and motor vehicle insurance statutes for your claim against the other driver. Section 440.39 of the 2026 Florida Statutes connects the two: you may pursue both, and your employer or its insurance carrier receives a defined share of what you recover.

In this guide

The Right Law Firm, P.A. does not handle workers’ compensation claims. That claim is a separate matter the firm may refer to another lawyer. This guide is general information for people in Plantation, Broward County and Palm Beach County, not legal advice, and each matter depends on its facts.

Workers’ compensation in brief

Under section 440.09(1), “The employer must pay compensation or furnish benefits required by this chapter if the employee suffers an accidental compensable injury or death arising out of work performed in the course and the scope of employment.” Section 440.10(1)(a) makes the employer “liable for, and shall secure, the payment to his or her employees” of that compensation, and section 440.10(2) says “Compensation shall be payable irrespective of fault as a cause for the injury,” subject to section 440.09(3). Under section 440.13(2)(a), the employer “shall furnish to the employee such medically necessary remedial treatment, care, and attendance” as the injury requires, within the chapter’s limits. Fault for the crash matters to the claim against the other driver, not, as a rule, to these benefits.

Why you generally cannot sue your employer or a co-worker

Section 440.11(1) says the employer’s liability under section 440.10 “shall be exclusive and in place of all other liability, including vicarious liability, of such employer to any third-party tortfeasor and to the employee” and anyone else entitled to recover for the injury, “except as follows:” and then states two exceptions. Paragraph (1)(a) applies “If an employer fails to secure payment of compensation as required by this chapter”; the employee then “may elect to claim compensation under this chapter or to maintain an action at law or in admiralty for damages.” Paragraph (1)(b) applies “When an employer commits an intentional tort that causes the injury or death of the employee,” which the statute recognizes “only when the employee proves, by clear and convincing evidence,” that “The employer deliberately intended to injure the employee” or that the conduct “was virtually certain to result in injury or death to the employee” under the conditions the subparagraph lists.

Co-workers share the shield. The same immunities “shall extend as well to each employee of the employer when such employee is acting in furtherance of the employer’s business and the injured employee is entitled to receive benefits under this chapter,” except a fellow employee who acts “with willful and wanton disregard or unprovoked physical aggression or with gross negligence” causing injury or death, or employees “assigned primarily to unrelated works.”

Your claim against the other driver survives

None of this protects a third party who hit you. Section 440.39(1) says an employee injured “by the negligence or wrongful act of a third-party tortfeasor” may “accept compensation benefits under the provisions of this law, and at the same time” pursue “his or her remedy by action at law or otherwise against such third-party tortfeasor.”

The employer or carrier’s lien

Under section 440.39(2), once the employee accepts benefits or begins proceedings for them, the employer or its insurer “shall be subrogated to the rights of the employee or his or her dependents against such third-party tortfeasor,” to the extent of benefits paid or to be paid. Under section 440.39(3)(a), the employer or carrier may file in the suit a notice of payment of compensation and medical benefits, “which notice shall constitute a lien upon any judgment or settlement recovered to the extent that the court may determine to be their pro rata share for compensation and medical benefits paid or to be paid,” less their pro rata share of the plaintiff’s costs and reasonable attorney’s fees. The same paragraph requires the employee to serve notice of the suit on the employer and carrier, and the employer and carrier to serve notice of payment of benefits on the employee and all parties.

How the carrier’s share is calculated

The statute states the formula. The employer or carrier first has “deducted from its recovery a percentage amount equal to the percentage of the judgment or settlement which is for costs and attorney’s fees.” Then: “Subject to this deduction, the employer or carrier shall recover from the judgment or settlement, after costs and attorney’s fees incurred by the employee or dependent in that suit have been deducted, 100 percent of what it has paid and future benefits to be paid, except, if the employee or dependent can demonstrate to the court that he or she did not recover the full value of damages sustained, the employer or carrier shall recover from the judgment or settlement, after costs and attorney’s fees incurred by the employee or dependent in that suit have been deducted, a percentage of what it has paid and future benefits to be paid equal to the percentage that the employee’s net recovery is of the full value of the employee’s damages.” The statute adds: “The burden of proof will be upon the employee.”

The one-year rule

Under section 440.39(4)(a), if the employee or dependents “fail to bring suit against such third-party tortfeasor within 1 year after the cause of action thereof has accrued,” the employer or carrier “may, after giving 30 days’ notice to the injured employee or his or her dependents and the injured employee’s attorney, if represented by counsel, institute suit against such third-party tortfeasor, either in his or her own name or as provided by subsection (3).” Under paragraph (4)(b), if the carrier or employer “does not bring suit within 2 years following the accrual of the cause of action against a third-party tortfeasor, the right of action shall revert to the employee.” How these periods interact with the two-year negligence limit below depends on the dates in your matter; this guide does not resolve that question.

How PIP fits with workers’ compensation

Section 627.736(4) addresses the overlap directly: “Benefits due from an insurer under ss. 627.730-627.7405 are primary, except that benefits received under any workers’ compensation law must be credited against the benefits provided by subsection (1) and are due and payable as loss accrues upon receipt of reasonable proof of such loss and the amount of expenses and loss incurred which are covered by the policy issued under ss. 627.730-627.7405.” PIP is ordinarily first in line, but workers’ compensation benefits you receive are credited against it.

Section 627.736(1) sets the benefit at “a limit of $10,000 in medical and disability benefits and $5,000 in death benefits,” and medical benefits are payable “if the individual receives initial services and care pursuant to subparagraph 1. within 14 days after the motor vehicle accident”; see our guide on the PIP 14-day rule. Subparagraph (1)(a)3. allows reimbursement “up to $10,000” when a listed provider has determined there was an “emergency medical condition,” and subparagraph (1)(a)4. limits it to “$2,500” when a listed provider determines there was not.

Whose PIP policy pays

The other driver’s PIP does not pay your bills. Under section 627.736(4)(e), “The insurer of the owner of a motor vehicle shall pay personal injury protection benefits for” the owner’s injury “while occupying a motor vehicle,” and for “any other person while occupying the owner’s motor vehicle” who does not own a vehicle requiring security and is not entitled to PIP from such an owner’s insurer. In general, if you own a motor vehicle that must carry this security, your own insurer pays even when you were driving a company vehicle; if you do not, the insurer of the vehicle you occupied pays, subject to the conditions in subparagraph (4)(e)4. and the resident-relative rules in (4)(e)3. Section 627.733(1)(a) requires that security, and section 324.022(1) requires property damage liability “in the amount of $10,000.” Neither requires bodily injury liability coverage; see uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, who pays medical bills while a claim is pending and documenting lost wages.

The claim against the other driver: the usual Florida rules

  • Pain and suffering threshold. Under section 627.737(2), damages “for pain, suffering, mental anguish, and inconvenience” are recoverable only if the injury consists in whole or in part of the permanent injury, significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement, or death that the subsection lists. The threshold governs those damages; medical expenses and lost income beyond PIP remain part of the claim.
  • Comparative fault. Under section 768.81(2), your own fault “diminishes proportionately the amount awarded” but “does not bar recovery, subject to subsection (6),” and subsection (6) says “any party found to be greater than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover any damages.” Section 30 of chapter 2023-15, Laws of Florida, applies the act “to causes of action filed after the effective date of this act,” March 24, 2023. See what happens when the other driver disputes fault.
  • Deadline. Under section 95.11(5)(a), “An action founded on negligence” must be commenced within two years. Section 28 of chapter 2023-15 makes that change “apply to causes of action accruing after the effective date of this act,” March 24, 2023. See Florida personal injury lawsuit deadlines.
  • Crash report. Under section 316.065(1), a driver in a crash resulting in injury, death or property damage “in an apparent amount of at least $2,000” must give notice to law enforcement “immediately by the quickest means of communication.” Under section 316.066(1)(a), a Long Form report is required when the crash “Resulted in death of, personal injury to, or any indication of complaints of pain or discomfort” or “Involved a commercial motor vehicle,” and under section 316.066(4) a person’s own report or statement to the officer “may not be used as evidence in any trial, civil or criminal.” See Florida traffic crash reports.

Rideshare and delivery app drivers

Workers’ compensation depends on being an employee. Section 627.748(9) states: “A TNC driver is an independent contractor and not an employee of the TNC if all of the following conditions are met:” the TNC “does not unilaterally prescribe specific hours during which the TNC driver must be logged on to the TNC’s digital network,” “does not prohibit the TNC driver from using digital networks from other TNCs,” “does not restrict the TNC driver from engaging in any other occupation or business,” and “The TNC and TNC driver agree in writing that the TNC driver is an independent contractor with respect to the TNC.” Whether a delivery or courier arrangement is employment under chapter 440 is a separate question. See our guide to Florida rideshare crash questions.

Common questions

Can I keep workers’ compensation benefits and still sue the other driver?

Yes. Section 440.39(1) lets the employee accept benefits “and at the same time” pursue the third-party tortfeasor, subject to the lien described above.

Does my employer’s insurance company get paid back from my settlement?

Under section 440.39(3)(a), after the costs and attorney’s fees you incurred in the suit are deducted and the carrier’s pro rata share of those costs and fees is deducted from its recovery, it recovers “100 percent of what it has paid and future benefits to be paid” unless the employee shows the court “that he or she did not recover the full value of damages sustained,” when the percentage formula applies.

Who pays my medical bills right after a work crash?

Section 440.13(2)(a) places the duty to furnish medically necessary treatment on the employer; section 627.736(4) makes PIP primary with workers’ compensation benefits credited against it. How they coordinate depends on the facts.

Related guides

For related topics, see our guides on Florida rideshare crash questions, the PIP 14-day rule, who pays medical bills while a claim is pending, documenting lost wages, Florida traffic crash reports, Florida personal injury lawsuit deadlines, what happens when the other driver disputes fault, and our accident consultation checklist.

Discuss your next step

The Right Law Firm, P.A. assists with Florida car and motor vehicle accident claims from its Plantation office. To request a free initial consultation, call 954-633-7744 or contact our team. Assistance is available in English and Spanish.

General information only. Each matter depends on its facts. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship; representation requires an agreement. Your case may be referred to another lawyer. Do not send confidential documents through the public inquiry form.

Sources and further reading