If the other driver says the crash was your fault, start by preserving what you already have: photographs, dashcam files, witness names, the crash report number, medical records and your insurance documents. In Florida, fault is decided later from evidence. What either driver says at the scene does not decide it. You do not need to prove fault before asking for help.

In this guide

This guide offers general information for drivers and families in Plantation and Broward County. It is not legal advice, and each matter depends on its facts.

What “disputed fault” means

A denial from the other driver, or from their insurer, is a position, not a ruling. Insurers, attorneys and, if a case is filed, a judge or jury may weigh the same facts differently. Fault can also be shared.

Shared fault matters in Florida. Under section 768.81, Florida Statutes, a person found more than 50 percent at fault for their own harm generally may not recover damages in a negligence case. At 50 percent or less, damages are generally reduced by that person’s share of fault. That is one reason an insurer may argue over percentages rather than simply deny a claim.

Your own PIP coverage comes first for injuries

Florida requires personal injury protection (PIP) coverage. For covered injuries, PIP generally pays from your own policy regardless of who caused the crash, so a fault dispute often runs alongside a PIP claim rather than replacing it. PIP does not pay for vehicle repairs. Property damage is handled through liability or your own collision coverage.

Under section 627.736, PIP generally covers 80 percent of reasonable medical expenses and 60 percent of lost income, up to a $10,000 limit. Medical benefits generally require initial services and care within 14 days after the crash. Benefits may be limited to $2,500 if a qualified provider does not determine that you had an emergency medical condition. Policy terms and exceptions apply.

Which records to gather first

  • Photographs of vehicle damage, the scene, road conditions and visible injuries.
  • Original dashcam files and a list of nearby cameras that may have recorded the crash.
  • Names and contact information for witnesses and passengers.
  • The crash report number and the investigating agency.
  • Medical records, bills and a list of providers you have seen.
  • Insurance cards, policy declarations and claim numbers.

Keep the originals unedited and make backups. A short written note made while the details are fresh can help later. Describe what you saw separately from what someone else told you.

Under section 316.065, the driver in a crash involving injury, death or apparent damage of at least $2,000 must immediately notify law enforcement. The Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles explains how to obtain crash reports and request the other party’s insurance information. For video, see our guide on how to preserve video after a Florida car accident.

How much the police report decides

A crash report is an important record, but it is not a verdict. Officers record what they observe and what people tell them. A citation or the report narrative does not settle fault in an insurance claim or civil case.

Florida law also limits how the report can be used. Under section 316.066(4), a crash report made by a person involved in the crash, and statements made to an officer to complete the report, may not be used as evidence in any civil or criminal trial, with limited exceptions. Other evidence, including what a witness personally observed, is handled under the rules of evidence.

Labels such as “Unit 1” and “Unit 2” identify the vehicles and drivers. They are not fault findings. Get your copy, read it carefully and note any errors or missing facts while you still remember them clearly.

What evidence can help when fault is denied

Evidence that does not depend on memory is often the most useful: video, photographs, vehicle damage patterns, scene measurements and, in some vehicles, event data recorder information. Independent witnesses and passengers may have seen what happened in the seconds before impact.

The questions usually turn on ordinary driving conduct: speed, following distance, distraction, right of way, traffic signals and turning. An attorney can review which records exist, who holds them and whether a preservation request is appropriate. Tell the attorney before a vehicle is repaired, sold or salvaged, or before a device is replaced.

If the other driver’s insurer will not accept fault

A denial is not necessarily the end of the claim. Depending on the facts and coverage, options may include providing additional evidence to the insurer, negotiating, pursuing your own available coverages, or filing a lawsuit. If the other driver files a claim against you, notify your own insurer promptly.

Florida limits claims for pain and suffering in many auto cases. Under section 627.737, those damages generally require a significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, a permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability, significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement, or death. Not every injury meets that threshold.

Deadlines apply. Under section 95.11, many negligence actions must be filed within two years, though the deadline for a particular matter depends on its facts. Do not wait for the fault dispute to resolve before asking about your deadline.

Mistakes that can make a disputed-fault claim harder

  • Arguing about fault with the other driver or giving a recorded statement to their insurer before you understand your situation.
  • Posting photographs, video or comments about the crash on social media.
  • Delaying medical care, which can affect PIP benefits and raise questions about the injury.
  • Editing, deleting or discarding photographs, video or damaged property.
  • Assuming there is no claim because there was no police report, or assuming the report settles fault.

Common questions

Do I need to prove fault before contacting an attorney?

No. Share what you know and the records you have. An attorney can help identify what is missing.

Does a citation for the other driver prove they were at fault?

Not by itself. A citation may be relevant, but fault in an insurance claim or civil case depends on all the evidence and the applicable rules.

Can I recover anything if I was partly at fault?

Possibly. Florida generally reduces damages by your share of fault and bars recovery if you are found more than 50 percent at fault. How fault is allocated depends on the evidence.

Discuss your next step

The Right Law Firm, P.A. assists with Florida car and motor vehicle accident claims from its Plantation office. To request a free initial consultation, call 954-633-7744 or contact our team. Assistance is available in English and Spanish.

General information only. Each matter depends on its facts. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship; representation requires an agreement. Do not send confidential documents through the public inquiry form.

Sources and further reading