Short answer: Generally, not because of the claim alone. Florida law bars an auto insurer from adding a surcharge or refusing to renew your policy solely because you were in an accident, unless it decides in good faith, from information in its file, that you were substantially at fault. A separate provision bars an extra charge for uninsured motorist (UM) coverage solely because of an accident. Your premium can still change for other reasons.
In this guide
This guide offers general information for people in Plantation and Broward County. It is not legal advice, and each matter depends on its facts.
Will using my PIP coverage raise my rates?
Not by itself, under Florida law. Florida’s no-fault law provides personal injury protection (PIP) benefits “without regard to fault” (section 627.731, Florida Statutes). If you own a car insured in Florida, your own PIP insurer generally pays your PIP benefits after a crash, whoever caused it (section 627.736(4)(e)).
What the law looks at is fault. Under section 626.9541(1)(o)3.a, Florida treats the following as an unfair or deceptive insurance practice:
“Imposing or requesting an additional premium for a policy of motor vehicle liability, personal injury protection, medical payment, or collision insurance or any combination thereof or refusing to renew the policy solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident unless the insurer’s file contains information from which the insurer in good faith determines that the insured was substantially at fault in the accident.”
In plain words, a crash alone is not a lawful reason to surcharge your liability, PIP, medical payments or collision coverage, or to refuse to renew your policy. The exception is a good-faith finding, based on the insurer’s file, that you were substantially at fault. The Florida Department of Financial Services describes the rule this way: section 626.9541 “protects consumers from an increase in their premium for filing a PIP claim in a not-at-fault accident” (Automobile Insurance Toolkit).
Will a UM claim raise my rates?
Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage can apply when you are legally entitled to recover damages for your injuries from a driver who has no bodily injury liability coverage, or too little to cover your damages (section 627.727(1) and (3)(b)). Because UM depends on another driver being legally responsible for your injuries, a UM claim usually comes from a crash someone else caused.
Florida also protects the price of the UM coverage itself. Under section 626.9541(1)(o)10, the following is an unfair or deceptive practice:
“Imposing or requesting an additional premium for motor vehicle comprehensive or uninsured motorist coverage solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident or was convicted of a moving traffic violation.”
That provision has no exception for accidents in which you were at fault. The general surcharge rule above still governs the other parts of your policy. For more on how UM coverage works, see our guide to uninsured and underinsured motorist questions.
Can my insurer remove a discount instead?
Not as a way around the surcharge rule. A rule of the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, Florida Administrative Code Rule 69O-175.002, says the surcharge prohibition “shall apply equally to insurers removing or eliminating a premium discount or credit because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident or was convicted of a moving traffic violation.” So where the law would not allow a surcharge for a crash, the insurer also may not remove a discount or credit, such as a discount for having no accidents, because of that crash.
How does an insurer decide whether I was “substantially at fault”?
The statute does not define “substantially at fault.” It leaves the first decision to the insurer, which must make it in good faith based on information in its file. The law then gives you two tools.
First, you can ask for the evidence. Under section 626.9541(1)(o)5, “Upon the request of the insured, the insurer and licensed agent shall supply to the insured the complete proof of fault or other criteria which justifies the additional charge or cancellation.”
Second, under section 626.9541(1)(o)3.b, an insurer that surcharges you or refuses to renew because of an accident must tell you, with the premium or nonrenewal notice, that it will refund the surcharge or renew the policy if you show that the driver of your car in the accident was:
- Lawfully parked;
- Reimbursed by, or on behalf of, a person responsible for the accident, or holding a judgment against that person;
- Struck in the rear by a vehicle headed in the same direction, and not convicted of a moving traffic violation in connection with the accident;
- Hit by a hit-and-run driver, if the accident was reported to the proper authorities within 24 hours after discovering it;
- Not convicted of a moving traffic violation in connection with the accident, when the other driver was convicted of one;
- Found not liable in a final court decision;
- Given a traffic citation that was dismissed or dropped (nolle prossed); or
- Not at fault, as shown by your written statement of the facts, unless information in the insurer’s file leads it to decide, in good faith, that you were substantially at fault.
If the other driver blames you, see our guide on disputed fault after a Florida car accident.
Can my insurer cancel or refuse to renew my policy after a claim?
For personal auto policies, cancellation and nonrenewal follow section 627.728. The broader notice statute, section 627.4133, excludes motor vehicle insurance subject to section 627.728.
- Cancellation. Once a policy has been in effect for 60 days, or if it is a renewal, the insurer may cancel it only for nonpayment of premium, material misrepresentation or fraud, or a suspended or revoked driver license or vehicle registration of the named insured or of another driver who lives in the household or regularly drives the insured car (section 627.728(2)). Being in an accident or making a claim is not on that list.
- Nonrenewal after an accident. The surcharge rule above also covers nonrenewal. Under section 626.9541(1)(o)3.c, an insurer “may not fail to renew a policy if the insured has had only one accident in which he or she was at fault within the current 3-year period.” The same paragraph allows nonrenewal for reasons other than accidents under section 627.728, and it does not prohibit nonrenewal when the insured has had three or more accidents, regardless of fault, in the most recent 3-year period.
- Notice. An insurer that will not renew must send at least 45 days’ advance notice, and the reasons must accompany it (section 627.728(4)(a)). If no written explanation comes with the notice, the statute says the policy “shall remain in full force and effect.”
Why did my premium go up if I was not at fault?
These protections limit surcharges tied to an accident. They do not freeze your premium. Rates can still change because of:
- Rate changes. Insurers set their rates and file them, and any changes, with the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (section 627.0651(1)). A rate change can raise or lower premiums for many customers at once, whether or not they had a claim.
- Driving record. An accident in which you were substantially at fault can lead to a surcharge. A surcharge based solely on a noncriminal traffic infraction is allowed only for a second infraction within 18 months, a third or later infraction within 36 months, or speeding more than 15 miles per hour over the limit (section 626.9541(1)(o)4).
- Changes to you, your car or your policy. Adding a driver or vehicle, changing coverage, moving or changing how a car is used can change the premium. The Department of Financial Services lists territory, vehicle type, driving history, vehicle use, age and credit history among rating factors (Automobile Insurance Toolkit).
What should I do if my renewal shows a surcharge?
- Compare the new premium notice with the last one, and look for an accident surcharge, a removed discount or a nonrenewal reason.
- Ask your insurer and agent, in writing, for the reason and for “the complete proof of fault or other criteria” behind the charge (section 626.9541(1)(o)5). Keep a copy and note the date you sent it.
- If one of the situations listed above applies, send proof, such as the crash report or citation record, and ask for a refund or renewal.
- If you cannot resolve it, contact the Florida Department of Financial Services Division of Consumer Services at 1-877-MY-FL-CFO (1-877-693-5236).
What deadlines should I keep in mind?
PIP has its own timing rules. PIP medical benefits require initial services and care within 14 days after the crash (section 627.736(1)(a)); see our guide to the Florida PIP 14-day rule. PIP pays up to $10,000 in medical and disability benefits (section 627.736(1)), and our guide on documenting lost wages after a Florida car accident explains what it pays toward lost income.
Deadlines also apply to lawsuits. Under section 95.11(5)(a), many negligence actions must be filed within two years, though the deadline for a particular matter depends on its facts. See our guide on Florida personal injury lawsuit deadlines, and use our consultation checklist to organize your insurance documents.
Common questions
Is a PIP claim an admission that I caused the crash?
Not by itself. PIP benefits are provided without regard to fault, so a PIP claim does not decide who caused the crash.
Can my rate go up if I was partly at fault?
It can, if the insurer decides in good faith that you were “substantially” at fault. Ask for the proof of fault it relied on.
How long can an accident surcharge last?
Under Rule 69O-175.008, an insurer may base an accident surcharge or nonrenewal only on accidents from the 36 months before the new or renewal policy takes effect, and the surcharge “may not remain in effect in excess of 36 months.”
Does the 24-hour rule matter after a hit-and-run?
It can. Being hit by a hit-and-run driver is one of the listed grounds for a refund or renewal, but only if the accident was reported to the proper authorities within 24 hours after discovering it. The rule against an extra charge for UM coverage applies either way. See our guide on what to do after a hit-and-run injury crash.
Discuss your next step
The Right Law Firm, P.A. assists with Florida car and motor vehicle accident claims from its Plantation office. To request a free initial consultation, call 954-633-7744 or contact our team.
General information only. Each matter depends on its facts. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship; representation requires an agreement. Your case may be referred to another lawyer. Do not send confidential documents through the public inquiry form.
Sources and further reading
- 2026 Florida Statutes, section 626.9541 (unfair insurance trade practices; accident surcharges)
- 2026 Florida Statutes, section 627.728 (motor vehicle cancellations; nonrenewals)
- 2026 Florida Statutes, section 627.4133 (notice of cancellation, nonrenewal, or renewal premium)
- 2026 Florida Statutes, section 627.736 (PIP benefits)
- 2026 Florida Statutes, section 627.731 (no-fault purpose)
- 2026 Florida Statutes, section 627.727 (uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage)
- 2026 Florida Statutes, section 627.0651 (motor vehicle insurance rates)
- 2026 Florida Statutes, section 95.11 (limitations)
- Florida Department of Financial Services, Automobile Insurance Toolkit
- Florida Department of Financial Services, Division of Consumer Services
